Private money disputes can’t be claimed as cyber fraud: HC | Delhi News


Private money disputes can’t be claimed as cyber fraud: HC
A metro train runs along a concrete viaduct on the right, approaching or leaving an elevated station with a curved, light-brown metal roof on the left. Dense green treetop foliage fills the midground, contrasting the concrete infrastructure. In the distance, urban buildings and residential layouts extend toward the horizon under a soft, slightly hazy sky. TOI Photo: Delhi News

New Delhi: Delhi High Court has clarified that the cyber fraud reporting mechanism cannot be invoked to undo a private dispute of voluntary contractual transactions between known parties.In a recent order, the HC directed the de-freezing of two bank accounts of a father and son in connection with a cyber complaint involving an alleged transfer of Rs 30 lakh and noted that the investigating agency had itself recorded that the dispute did not disclose the ingredients of cyber fraud and that the amount had been voluntarily transferred through banking channels by the account holder or her family members.“Permitting the continued freezing of the petitioners’ accounts in such circumstances would result in a private dispute between known parties being given the complexion of a cyber-fraud case,” HC observed as it took note of the different versions given in the original and supplementary complaints.The case arose from a property transaction dating back to July 2013, when the father agreed to purchase the third floor of a property in Karol Bagh, along with roof and terrace rights, for a total consideration of Rs 60 lakh. He paid Rs 30 lakh as earnest money to the company concerned.After the company allegedly failed to execute the sale deed, he instituted a suit in 2016.The parties subsequently decided to settle the dispute through a refund of Rs 30 lakh in exchange for withdrawal of the civil suit. A settlement deed was executed on March 16, 2026, and the amount was transferred to the father’s bank account in four tranches on March 17.Thereafter, the father transferred the amount to his son’s bank account as part of a family arrangement.However, on March 18, a cyber complaint was lodged by the daughter of the woman who returned the money, alleging internet banking-related fraud and claiming that her mother had mistakenly transferred the amount.The petitioners subsequently discovered that their bank accounts stood frozen and a lien had been marked on them, prompting them to move HC seeking quashing of the cyber complaint and de-freezing of their accounts.During the proceedings, the investigating agency informed the court that it had examined the father and considered documents including the agreement to sell, orders passed in the civil proceedings, the settlement deed and CCTV footage, adding that it had no objection to the accounts being de-frozen but submitted that the disputed Rs 30 lakh should continue to remain on hold until completion of the enquiry.HC, however, declined to put a lien but also didn’t quash the cyber complaint, leaving the parties to take legal remedies.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *